Price of gold, price of silver.
In March 2013 the U.S.A.’s Commodity Futures Trading Commission was looking into, but not formally investigating, possible gold and silver price manipulations in London, the world’s largest gold market. The F.A.Z. mentioned they were especially interested in the “too-intransparent” way the spot price for a troy ounce of gold is set in London twice a day by five banks: Barclays, Deutsche Bank, HSBC Holdings, PLC, Bank of Nova Scotia and Société Générale S.A. The silver price in London is set once per day, at noon, by Bank of Nova Scotia, Deutsche Bank and HSBC. A March 2013 article in Rupert Murdoch’s Wall Street Journal mentioned that the market prices for these metals were important also for the estimated ~$198 million in derivative contracts held by commercial banks in the U.S.A. in September 2012, according to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (O.C.C.).
The C.F.T.C. started investigating whether the price of silver had been gamed in 2008 after the silver price fell sharply. No results were ever announced from that investigation, nor was it ever officially closed.
Update on 25 Sep 2013: The C.F.T.C. officially closed its five-year investigation into gaming of silver market prices “without bringing any enforcement actions” reported Bloomberg.com.
Update on 27 Nov 2013: Germany’s BaFin financial regulator announced they would be investigating possible manipulation of gold and silver prices, which Handelsblatt.com said would be called das Goldfixing and das Silberfixing in German. BaFin said that they could not comment on the ongoing investigation but that they were interested in benchmark manipulation in Europe, including benchmarks for the so-called noble metals, currencies and interest rates. Gold and silver prices had been being set by benchmarks controlled by only a handfull of European banks, the Handelsblatt said Wall Street Journal Deutschland said, and alleged that British financial authorities were looking into gold and silver price gaming as well.
Update on 09 May 2014: A wave of U.S. lawsuits is said to be rolling toward the five banks that set the gold price twice each day in London.
The Frankfurter Allgemeine reported on the findings of one analyst, who will be testifying for the plaintiffs, from examining publicly available gold price data from 2010 to 2013. The banks’ twice-daily phone conferences to set the price could take two minutes or two hours, but averaged 15 minutes. During that time, there were bigger fluctuations in the gold price than during the rest of the day when the phone conferences weren’t taking place. The price moved up and down but mostly downward. After the teleconference, the price settled back to where it was before the meeting. During the phone conferences, the banks had access to information their customers did not: the volume of gold being traded, and the prices at which they were trading. That information wasn’t supposed to be shared, but. The U.S. plaintiffs say, look at L.I.B.O.R.
Deutsche Bank is now withdrawing from the five banks, leaving four banks: Barclays, HSBC, Bank of Nova Scotia and Société Générale.
Update on 16 Aug 2014: The price of silver will now be set electronically by auction, in a service offered by the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and Thomson Reuters.
(GOALED prize, ZILLLL beh prize)